Cecil A. Wright Memorial Lecture

Cecil A. Wright Memorial Lecture

2027 Cecil A. Wright Memorial Lecture

Adrienne Stone, Melbourne Laureate Professor 
Thursday, January 7, 2027 - 4:30pm to 6:00pm
Location: J140, Professor A.V. Dicey Classroom

If you require accommodation(s) please contact events.law@utoronto.ca

adrienne stone

Adrienne Stone, Melbourne Laureate Professor

 Academic Freedom and Knowledge: Some Hard Questions

Two widespread points of consensus about academic freedom provide the starting point for this lecture: First, despite much confusion on the point in public debate, academic freedom is not to be equated with, nor seen as an aspect of, freedom of speech. Second academic freedom is best justified as a norm that secures the conditions for knowledge creation.

This lecture will address difficult questions that follow from these propositions. The first set of questions follow from the distinction between academic freedom and freedom of speech: if academic freedom is not to be equated with freedom of speech, can it be conceived of as some other kind of a right, or in rights terms at all?

The second two questions follow from the knowledge conception of academic freedom: If academic freedom is justified by its contribution to knowledge, we need to answer the question of how research produces knowledge. That question is easily answered by some disciplines but in others it is quite vexed and contested. Given the methodological diversity of legal scholarship, the contributions made by scholars of law are highly diverse and they include implicit forms of knowledge that legal scholars have and communicate to others. The lecture then turns to a final hard question that follows from the knowledge-based conception of academic freedom: ‘what are the limits of an academic’s expertise’, a question that is especially difficult to answer in the context of public commentary.

The modern law school at U of T was founded in 1949. Building on the tradition of the academic study of law spearheaded by Professor W.P.M Kennedy, Dean Cecil "Caesar" Wright and his colleagues rejected the profession-led, apprenticeship-oriented model of legal training that prevailed in Ontario at the time and established U of T’s Faculty of Law.

This re-conception of legal education has proven to be the enduring key to our success and has carried the Law Faculty to pre-eminence among law schools in Canada and in the world.

Jackman Law invites world-renowned academics to share their insights at this annual lecture named after Dean Wright.